To compare AI integration providers for your business applications and your ERP, give them all the same use case, score them on the same weighted scorecard and demand evidence: a comparable integration in production, a data security plan and a maintenance setup. Don’t stop at the upfront price: compare the total cost over several years and the provider’s ability to keep the solution running.
Why integration matters more than the AI model
AI models are now widely available. What makes the difference is everything around them: access to the right ERP data, respect for each user’s permissions, human approval, traceability and maintenance. A provider that knows AI but not your ERP architecture is taking risks with your data. The reverse is also a problem. You need both skill sets.
Step 1: prepare a shared use case
Before reaching out, write a one-page brief that covers:
- the target process (order processing, invoice matching, answering staff questions, forecasting, etc.);
- the systems to connect (ERP, PLM, CRM, document management) and their versions;
- what the AI may only suggest, and what it may execute;
- sensitive data and hosting constraints;
- the success metric: time saved, errors avoided, processing time.
Send the same document to every provider. It’s the only way to get proposals you can compare like for like.
Step 2: score AI integration providers on a weighted scorecard
| Criterion | Suggested weight | What to check |
|---|---|---|
| Understanding of the business process | 15% | The provider restates your need and proposes a measurable metric |
| Expertise in your ERP and applications | 20% | Experience with your ERP, its APIs and its upgrade constraints |
| Integration architecture | 15% | APIs, error handling, system of record for each piece of data |
| AI quality | 10% | Model choice, tests on your real cases, handling of wrong answers |
| Security and compliance | 15% | Access rights, logging, data hosting, GDPR, AI Act |
| Method and team | 10% | Pilot, acceptance testing, named and available team |
| Maintenance and reversibility | 10% | Monitoring, code ownership, ability to switch models |
| Total cost | 5% | Build, licenses, model usage, maintenance |
Score from 1 to 5, multiply by the weight and add up. Treat security and compliance as deal-breakers: a high score elsewhere does not make up for a gap here.
Step 3: demand evidence
- A comparable integration in production: for how long, and with what results.
- An architecture diagram: where the data flows, who can access it, what gets logged.
- A demo on your data (or an anonymized copy), rather than a generic demo.
- A pilot plan on a limited scope, with success criteria set in advance.
- The resumes of the team actually assigned.
6 questions that separate the providers
- How will the AI respect each user’s access rights in the ERP?
- Which actions can the AI take on its own, and which will need approval?
- Will our data be used to train a model? Where will it be hosted?
- How will you measure answer quality, before and after go-live?
- What happens if the model provider changes its prices or terms?
- Who maintains the solution when the ERP is upgraded?
The full list, with what to put in the contract: 20 questions to ask an AI provider before you sign. To understand what to expect from such a provider, see also AI integration partner: definition and role.
Red flags
- Promised results before any analysis of your processes and data.
- Vague answers on security or hosting.
- A project that stops at the pilot, with no plan for production.
- A closed solution, with no access to the code and no way to switch models.
- A low quote that includes neither maintenance nor model usage.
Our approach at Tocndix
Tocndix integrates AI into business applications hands-on, inside your organization: our Forward Deployed Engineers work embedded in your teams, all the way to production. We connect applications to ERPs (SAP, Priority) and to Siemens Teamcenter, and we build on Mendix when it makes sense, so you don’t have to rebuild everything. Every engagement is fixed-price, with the price set after a scoping phase.
Explore our AI integration services, read how much an AI agent costs in production or request a scoping session.
FAQ
Do you need an ERP integrator or an AI specialist?
Ideally, a provider that is strong in both, or a pair of providers working together from the scoping stage. AI without ERP expertise puts your data at risk. ERP without AI expertise delivers disappointing results.
How many providers should you invite to bid?
Two or three, with the same use case and the same scorecard. Beyond that, the effort of comparing outweighs the benefit.
Should you start with a pilot?
Yes, on a single, measurable process. The pilot should already use your real data and real access rights, and include a plan for moving to production.
Isn’t the copilot built into the ERP enough?
For a simple first use case on data already in the ERP, it may be. As soon as the AI has to combine several systems or follow a process specific to your company, a custom integration becomes necessary.